Listen to this story.
Dog being bathed
Photo by fotoedu/Depositphotos.com
Wastewater from bathing dogs has been identified as a source of environmental contamination by fipronil, the active ingredient in many topical flea-and-tick-control products for pets.
California is considering limiting the sale of a chemical commonly used to manage fleas and ticks in household pets, citing mounting evidence that it poses risks to aquatic life and human health. One option on the table is to restrict the use of the chemical, fipronil, to pest control professionals.
Fipronil is the active ingredient in dozens of topical treatments, also known as spot-ons, that are applied to the skin of dogs and cats. Popular brands containing fipronil include Frontline Plus and PetArmor Plus.
An expanding body of research, much of it conducted in California and the United Kingdom, has found that the products contaminate waterways after being washed down drains when pets are bathed or owners clean their hands or when pets swim outdoors.
Spot-ons are valued for their effectiveness, ease of use and relatively low toxicity in mammals, including humans. However, in addition to killing disease-carrying fleas and ticks, their active ingredients also can kill tiny aquatic insects that are a crucial food source for fish and birds.
Moreover, the California Department of Pesticide Regulation (CDPR) has found that spot-ons containing fipronil can expose groomers, pet owners and children to dangerous levels of the chemical. It has identified groomers as being at greater risk, since they may come into contact with multiple animals per day. The department found that adult pet owners are most vulnerable to dermal exposure from petting and children are at risk from both dermal exposure and incidental oral ingestion from hand-to-mouth contact.
That and other supporting evidence are in documents made public yesterday by the CDPR, including a memorandum outlining mitigation options. The department has invited public comment on its proposals through Nov. 16.
Other proposed measures are consumer education campaigns or label changes, such as limiting the number of spot-on applications to three per year instead of the typical 12 and a seven-day bathing restriction immediately following application.
Alternatively, fipronil could be designated as a restricted material, sold only by CDPR-licensed pest control dealers. Purchasers would need an applicator license from the department and a restricted materials permit from the local County Agricultural Commissioner (CAC). The applicator would then have to submit a "notice of intent" to the CAC before applying the product.
The CDPR noted that most licensed applicators generally are professional agricultural companies or pest controllers that target vermin in buildings — not pet groomers and household users.
"Therefore, designating fipronil as a restricted material is likely to result in an overall reduction in use and in turn a decrease in fipronil loading into wastewater," the agency said.
The California Veterinary Medical Association, which has around 7,000 veterinarian members, did not reply immediately to a request for comment. In February, its executive director at the time, Dan Baxter, said in a letter to the CDPR that fipronil-based spot-ons largely have been replaced by newer and more effective treatments.
Still, Baxter noted that many people struggle to afford veterinary care and that fipronil "is still widely relied upon" by Californian pet owners to control parasites.
"Despite its demonstrable contribution to improving household health by combatting parasites, the CVMA finds the multiple [CDPR] studies about fipronil’s effect on the environment and on wildlife species to be compelling," Baxter wrote. "While the profession would face minimal inconvenience if the pesticide were to be eliminated, it also recognizes the benefit of the pesticide to both animal and human health. Both the benefits and the consequences of this pesticide should be carefully considered should an effort to further regulate or ban fipronil be made."
While California appears to be the first state in the United States to consider imposing restrictions on the use of fipronil in spot-ons, similar moves are afoot in the United Kingdom.
In April, the U.K. government said it was considering confining the sale of spot-ons to veterinarians and pharmacists, citing evidence that the products are contaminating the environment, particularly waterways. Subsequently, in August, a parliamentary committee recommended that restrictions be placed on their use.
The U.K. has included in its considerations a second chemical that is common in spot-ons. Imidacloprid, the active ingredient in brands such as Advantage and Evance, also has been found by British and U.S. research to contaminate waterways.
Researchers on both sides of the Atlantic maintain that spot-on pet products are likely a large contributor to waterway contamination because the use of fipronil and imidacloprid in agriculture is either banned or otherwise uncommon in many places, including the U.K. Fipronil has never been licensed for agricultural use in California. Urban uses there include sprays for the outdoor perimeter of buildings to control ants and other insects, underground injections to control termites, gels for crack-and-crevice treatment and baits for insect control.
The CDPR told the VIN News Service that it confined its investigation to fipronil because that chemical has limited uses in California compared with imidacloprid, which is permitted for agricultural use in the state. Its investigation of fipronil, it said, began with CDPR research published in 2017 that found that spot-ons containing fipronil washed off pets for as as long as 28 days after they were applied.
"We focused on fipronil in the pet washoff study because its limited uses – mostly in pet products – allow wastewater results to be interpreted with much clearer insight than would be possible for imidacloprid, which has many potential sources," the CDPR said in an email.
Still, the agency said it has latitude to investigate other chemicals. "While fipronil was prioritized for mitigation, [CDPR] continuously evaluates a broad range of pesticides and can initiate risk assessments or reevaluation of any active ingredient when data indicate potential adverse effects," it said. The agency added that it welcomed public comment on the environmental profile of all spot-on products.
On Wednesday, the CDPR also released an economic evaluation in which it said it had identified and analyzed the costs of 143 spot-on products, including 54 containing fipronil and 89 "alternative spot-on pet products" that don't contain fipronil. The products it included came in the form of liquids, creams, gels, shampoos, sprays and collars. It then used sales data to compare the costs of the products containing fipronil with the alternatives.
Should fipronil products become unavailable to Californians, the CDPR estimated the collective statewide cost for users would increase by $326,611 per year. That number, it explained, corresponds to an average increase in monthly cost of $0.56 per dog and $3.64 per cat for owners currently using fipronil spot-ons. The analysis does not mention potential contamination risks associated with the alternative spot-on products, which contain pesticides such as imidacloprid and permethrin.
Fleas and ticks in pets also can be managed with oral medications, such as chews. Such products are classified as drugs rather than pesticides so are not regulated by the CDPR.
This story was updated on Sept. 21 to include a response from the CDPR.